In the fast-paced world of modern work, feedback often gets a bad rap. For many, hearing “we need to talk” strikes dread into their professional hearts. But tough conversations don’t have to be feared—they can become powerful catalysts for growth. When handled thoughtfully, feedback isn’t about judgement; it’s about unlocking potential. Let’s explore how to make that shift, using the psychology behind feedback, helpful models, and a more human approach to delivering it.
Why Tough Feedback Feels Tough
It’s no surprise that receiving feedback can feel like a punch to the ego. At the core of that discomfort is a cocktail of human instincts:
- Threat to identity – When our work is criticised, it can feel personal. That’s the amygdala kicking in, flooding us with a stress response.
- Mindset matters – According to psychologist Carol Dweck, those with a fixed mindset see feedback as proof of failure. Those with a growth mindset treat it as a signal for development.
Understanding the science behind our reactions allows us to take feedback less personally—and to deliver it more effectively.
Reframing Feedback Conversations
Tough feedback doesn’t have to sound tough. With small shifts in language and tone, we can make these conversations feel like collaboration, not confrontation.
- Ask instead of tell: “Can you walk me through your thinking on this?” opens more than “You didn’t do that right.”
- Be precise and kind: Instead of “You’re not proactive,” try: “The report was submitted a day late, which affected the project timeline.”
- Focus on the bigger picture: Starting with “Our goal is to improve delivery times, so let’s look at…” brings people into shared purpose.
Reframing is about building trust—creating space where learning can happen. It’s a principle that also underpins good design thinking: just as in professional interior design, where personalisation trumps generic inspiration, human-centred feedback creates better outcomes.
Simple Frameworks That Work
Using feedback models provides structure and prevents conversations from going off track. Here are two that make things easier for both sides:
SBI (Situation–Behaviour–Impact)
- Situation: “In Monday’s meeting…”
- Behaviour: “…you cut off Alex while she was speaking…”
- Impact: “…and it stopped the idea from being fully heard.”
It keeps things focused and factual.
BOOST (Balanced, Observed, Objective, Specific, Timely)
A quick way to check if your feedback will land well. Is it:
- Balanced – Does it include positives and areas to grow?
- Observed – Based on what actually happened?
- Objective and Specific – No vague feelings, just clear details.
- Timely – Delivered soon after the event?
For example: “You managed the client call well, though the pricing details were left out. Next time, let’s double-check that before wrapping up.”
Making Feedback Feel Constructive
Even the best models won’t work without the right mindset and preparation. Here are a few practical tips to make feedback feel less awkward and more helpful:
- Take a moment before diving in – Emotion can cloud delivery.
- Use reflective listening – Echo their words back: “So you felt left out of that decision?”
- Invite action – “What’s one thing we could do differently next time?”
- Follow up – It shows commitment and builds trust.
- Recognise wins – Positive reinforcement keeps people motivated.
It’s not about being soft—it’s about being effective.
Feedback in Group Settings: Going Deeper
Sometimes, the best feedback doesn’t come from the top down—it comes from peers. Group sessions, when done well, foster reflection and growth in a more open, collaborative way. But they need structure.
This is where facilitated workshops shine. They provide safe, neutral environments where people feel comfortable sharing and listening. If you’re looking to build this into your culture, consider doing it with insights discovery workshops, which use personality profiling and guided facilitation to unlock deeper team understanding.
The Business Case: Why Feedback Drives Results
Handled well, feedback doesn’t just improve people—it lifts entire teams.
- Increased engagement: According to Gallup, teams that receive regular, quality feedback are more engaged and committed.
- Better relationships: Open, respectful communication strengthens team bonds.
- Improved outcomes: Small course corrections prevent big problems later.
Case in point: A London-based creative agency implemented monthly peer-feedback sessions using the SBI model. Over three months, internal surveys showed a 20% rise in team satisfaction and fewer missed deadlines. Team members said they felt more “seen” and supported.
Just like strategic improvements to a living space, structured feedback can transform how a team performs and how individuals feel within it.
Use Facilitation to Make It Stick
If you’re leading teams or running workshops, facilitation can make all the difference in how feedback is received. From warm-ups to wrap-ups, the right approach sets the tone for openness.
Looking to refine your approach? Try incorporating techniques that give everyone a voice and help shift the dynamic from passive to participatory. Facilitation works best when it encourages people to feel ownership over outcomes—especially when navigating tough feedback.
Turning Feedback Into Culture
So how do we make feedback not just something we do—but something we live?
| Step | What to Try |
| 1. Start small | Use SBI in your next one-to-one. |
| 2. Build rhythm | Add “one piece of feedback I’d like” to your team meetings. |
| 3. Create space | Run short peer-feedback circles monthly. |
| 4. Check in | After a month, ask the team what’s changed. |
| 5. Celebrate effort | Recognise when someone acts on feedback, even in small ways. |
Like any habit, it takes time. But it’s worth it.
Final Thoughts: Feedback as Fuel
Feedback will never be completely free of discomfort. But it can become a source of connection, learning, and strength. With the right models, mindset and support, tough talks turn into the very moments that help us grow.
Start small. Try a model. Shift your tone. And watch how the conversation changes—not just in words, but in outcomes.
Leave a Reply